What oil. Colchester master

[roofman]

Common sense hour. If it said to use any grade of oil, it would.

Fill your car engine up with iso 46 and report back.

Thats not the answer i was expecting fella..for the last 20 years i have been using normal 10/40 oil mixed for all my 2 stroke plant, i have a Stihl leaf blower i bought in 2003 and its still on its same piston and bore using it...Now thats a real life explanation of my experience by having no common sense according to the books. Without sounding argumentative can you back up your claim in post 18? as i am genuinely interested.

 

[Johnnybravo]

ISO 32.

 

[Johnnybravo]

Thats not the answer i was expecting fella..for the last 20 years i have been using normal 10/40 oil mixed for all my 2 stroke plant, i have a Stihl leaf blower i bought in 2003 and its still on its same piston and bore using it...Now thats a real life explanation of my experience by having no common sense according to the books. Without sounding argumentative can you back up your claim in post 18? as i am genuinely interested.

Irrelevant. Start your own leaf blowing thread if you must…

 

[roofman]

Irrelevant. Start your own leaf blowing thread if you must…

wife said no tonight darling?

 

[merryman]

Do not use EP in any gearbox or axle unless the EP oil says suitable for yellow metals on the tin, or you know that the box has no copper or brass parts in it, and remember once upon a time, lots of ball races had brass cages, selector forks are often brass too. Plus some machine gearboxes have external oilways piped though copper bundy.

 

[Johnnybravo]

wife said no tonight darling?

Mature . Go grind your axe and your ill formed wit elsewhere. Your clever remarks make you look like a bigger tit that you probably are. The OP asked a genuine question, not a free pass to your third rate comedy routine

 

[minimutly]

As above,
Moderm multigades are detergent oils and carry the contaminants in suspension in the oil to be filtered by the oil filter. Hydraulic / machine oil lets the deposits drop to the bottom of the case.

Every old mini gearbox (road ones, not competition) I've stripped has had a layer of black metal and carbon oil stuck to the bottom. Ok that's not to say the oil wasn't rying to prevent this of course, but I suspect much of that would be hype - really, in a lathe, what will detergent do? No carbon in there from combustion, so what's the issue?

 

[roofman]

Mature . Go grind your axe and your ill formed wit elsewhere. Your clever remarks make you look like a bigger tit that you probably are. The OP asked a genuine question, not a free pass to your third rate comedy routine

The only input to this thread and you throw this out...genuine question from me to a post made regarding oil you bell end.

 

[Johnnybravo]

Every old mini gearbox (road ones, not competition) I've stripped has had a layer of black metal and carbon oil stuck to the bottom. Ok that's not to say the oil wasn't rying to prevent this of course, but I suspect much of that would be hype - really, in a lathe, what will detergent do? No carbon in there from combustion, so what's the issue?

Engine or gearbox oil is too thick and you will muller the spindle bearings due to inadequate lubrication as it would take too long to heat the oil adequately to get it thin enough to lubricate in the same manner as the originally specified oil.Ep additive oils also muller yellow bearings. You can find certain gear oils that are specifically yellow metal safe,but the viscosity issue remains the same.You want whatever contaminants in the oil from clutch or gear wear to drop out of suspension. This is the exact opposite of what detergent laden engine oils promote. If you had a full flow pressurised oil filtering system on your lathe like your car has,this wouldn’t be an issue .

 

[minimutly]

Now now gentlemen.....

 

[Johnnybravo]

The only input to this thread and you throw this out...genuine question from me to a post made regarding oil you bell end.

Grow up

 

[roofman]

Grow up

ime out

 

[minimutly]

Engine or gearbox oil is too thick and you will muller the spindle bearings due to inadequate lubrication as it would take too long to heat the oil adequately to get it thin enough to lubricate in the same manner as the originally specified oil.

10/30 is a lot thinner than the treacle I pulled out of my triumph. That's a fact.
Aaaand, "the originally specified oil" was what was generally used back in 1950 something...
In a straight fight between the two I would bet on anything running modern 10/30 the nod anytime.

 

[Dieselman 63]

Or just use an oil that the manufacturer specified and keep your machine in good health… maybe? It’s pretty cheap compared to rebuilding a headstock

Westway Oils

www.westwayoils.co.uk

 

[Johnnybravo]

10/30 is a lot thinner than the treacle I pulled out of my triumph. That's a fact.

Doesn’t mean the oil you replaced was correct in the first place. Your lathe,your choice. Machine manufacturer now suggests ISO 32, that’s what I will use

 

[minimutly]

Or just use an oil that the manufacturer specified and keep your machine in good health… maybe? It’s pretty cheap compared to rebuilding a headstock

Westway Oils

www.westwayoils.co.uk

I get it - use the specified oil, if you want. But really, bearings are bearings, gears are gears, and lathe gears used in home workshops, and even repair workshops are not worked hard. Even if they were, it would be a good oil that beat the ability of modern engine oils.
If you don't agree fine - go take a look at anything made by Mr Honda, Mr Kawasaki, Mr Yamaha or others since the 60's....

 

[Dieselman 63]

I get it - use the specified oil, if you want. But really, bearings are bearings, gears are gears, and lathe gears used in home workshops, and even repair workshops are not worked hard. Even if they were, it would be a good oil that beat the ability of modern engine oils.
If you don't agree fine - go take a look at anything made by Mr Honda, Mr Kawasaki, Mr Yamaha or others since the 60's....

Yeah but Gamet bearings…

 

[AHTI123]

Cheers for the replies. Glad I asked the question.

 

[minimutly]

Yeah but Gamet bearings…

Are just bearings, not bushes, bronze or otherwise.

 

[roofman]

Found this...might be handy for some one.

Lathes - Precision RPM Inc.

www.precisionrpm.com