Arc rods

[Robert Mullins]

This has opened a whole can of worms, a welding engineer where I used to work, said that the new practise within the oil refinery/pipe line is to remove, and reweld butt welds as steel continues to absorb hydrogen with the passage of time: but according to what your saying, this is a temporary and the hydrogen will escape within 72 hours

 

[TechnicAl]

This has opened a whole can of worms, a welding engineer where I used to work, said that the new practise within the oil refinery/pipe line is to remove, and reweld butt welds as steel continues to absorb hydrogen with the passage of time: but according to what your saying, this is a temporary and the hydrogen will escape within 72 hours

Unless the weld is frozen the hydrogen will escape with time....heat will speed it up....72 hours is the usual time allowed between welding and NDT....usually any cracks will have appeared by then.........Ive never heard of welds having to be cut out and replaced because they have absorbed hydrogen........the vast majority of the hydrogen comes from the welding

Are you referring to sour pipe lines where H2S Hydrogen Sulphide is present......if so thats corrosion....http://himipex.com/the-problem-of-protection-of-metal-from-the-hydrogen-sulfide-corrosion

 

[Robert Mullins]

I was told about this in the late 90's, and from memory it was as I said, refinery, oil line work: i'mi' still in contact with Malcolm, I'll ask him

 

[Munkul]

a welding engineer where I used to work, said that the new practise within the oil refinery/pipe line is to remove, and reweld butt welds as steel continues to absorb hydrogen with the passage of time

Sounds like he's maybe picked up the wrong end of the stick? Only reason to cut out and reweld is if they used the wrong filler metal to start with, or if the welds carried out are subject to sulphide stress cracking at a different rate to the rest of the pipework parent metal... possibly a combination of both reasons...? If it's sour service then usually the pipe material AND the weld procedures would be NACE approved. It could be because the original welds should have been post heat treated, and they left it too late, so as a precaution they're rewelding the lot...

 

[Mpm welding]

One thing I've always noticed is that you all get wrapped in the technical aspect of a given electrode, metallurgy and properties etc etc. The gentleman would find 7018's wholly unsuitable for one reason, you have to use the lot and can't store them properly, unless you have a rod oven and a quiver to heat them before using. Or ALL these magic properties are for nought. Hence why we all in the UK love are smooth 6013's. Plus 7018's are a swine on re-strike, although I just crank up my amps to counter this. I have a plethora of makes/types, enough for TechnicAl to be in his element in fact, plus I know Mjb knows his stuff, but I have been reading posts on here for a while now and it was one of the things I remember, as a novice, I was blinded with esoteric info. Rods, all day everyday the best? Esab ok46.00 6013's of what dreams are made ! If you had a hand in the ok46.00 electrodes development TecchnicAl I'll buy you a pint or 3! Any newbs reading don't confuse these with the ok46.30, although they're pretty good too.

 

[Lewis_RX8]

Stay clear of super6 rods also. Had nothing but issues with them. Currently using boc premium rods and bohler rods far better.

Im no expert myself but get on very well with the BOC Premium rods get from a local industry welding supplier £12 for 5kg including vat and a lot better than machine mart specials

 

[Mpm welding]

Been meaning to try them, got an account with BOC so I'll give them a go as ok46.00 ain't cheap!

 

[Lewis_RX8]

Have not tried esab ok rods heard good words about them however only i can only compare the BOC to Machine Mart and some old SIP rods.

Have seen they are a bit pricy however

 

[TechnicAl]

One thing I've always noticed is that you all get wrapped in the technical aspect of a given electrode, metallurgy and properties etc etc. The gentleman would find 7018's wholly unsuitable for one reason, you have to use the lot and can't store them properly, unless you have a rod oven and a quiver to heat them before using. Or ALL these magic properties are for nought. Hence why we all in the UK love are smooth 6013's. Plus 7018's are a swine on re-strike, although I just crank up my amps to counter this. I have a plethora of makes/types, enough for TechnicAl to be in his element in fact, plus I know Mjb knows his stuff, but I have been reading posts on here for a while now and it was one of the things I remember, as a novice, I was blinded with esoteric info. Rods, all day everyday the best? Esab ok46.00 6013's of what dreams are made ! If you had a hand in the ok46.00 electrodes development TecchnicAl I'll buy you a pint or 3! Any newbs reading don't confuse these with the ok46.30, although they're pretty good too.

Sorry to say that I never worked for Esab but I know a story about the 46........Lincoln bought a Spanish manufacturer called KD who made a KD46 for many years...It was considered one of the best 6013s on the market....so much so that one or two others launched products with 46 in the name. I was told that the guy who developed it left KD and joined Esab not long before they launched the 46.00

Do I still qualify for the pint or 3?

 

[Mpm welding]

Knew you'd know something about them! Lol I'm a bit of an electrode saddo, in that I've tried all processes and love stick welding, don't know why? Stick, tig then mig for me. Due to that fact the few years I've been into this welding malarkey, I've tried a LOT of different types, ALL types not makes of course used. Helps that I can get 304, 316 and steel in general quite cheap, ok really cheap, that I can play about.
Yes, pint qualifies. I must've read a load of posts with you in anyway so I owe you for teaching me stuff. YouTube and forums are good tools to get into this complex thing called welding. Goodnight all got work tomorrow, oh well !

 

[Munkul]

The gentleman would find 7018's wholly unsuitable for one reason, you have to use the lot and can't store them properly, unless you have a rod oven and a quiver to heat them before using. Or ALL these magic properties are for nought. Hence why we all in the UK love are smooth 6013's.

Plenty people use 7018 without a rod oven for general purpose work. They're still stronger and tougher than 6013 on mild steel.

You've just lost the "h4" or "h5" designation that you'd need for highly restrained weldments, or low alloy steel, etc, which is susceptible for hydrogen cracking. Obviously no good for code work, either.

They are a pain to re-strike, though! I knock the glassy end off on concrete usually.

 

[TechnicAl]

Sorry to say that I never worked for Esab but I know a story about the 46........Lincoln bought a Spanish manufacturer called KD who made a KD46 for many years...It was considered one of the best 6013s on the market....so much so that one or two others launched products with 46 in the name. I was told that the guy who developed it left KD and joined Esab not long before they launched the 46.00

Do I still qualify for the pint or 3?

I remembered a bit more later on.........KD in Spain (who made the KD46) actually made the Esab OK 46.00 for many years, until they were bought by Lincoln. So both Lincoln KD and Esab had a problem......KD needed to sell them elsewhere and Esab had to get a replacement....thats when they recruited the Technical guy from Spain....

 

[Robert Mullins]

I know pipe welders that only ever strike a rod up once, no matter how much remains, it's discarded

 

[TechnicAl]

If you notice most 7018s and 7016s have a graphite tip.....we used to metal spray some but its only possible on the bigger diameters (too many smaller ones get missed),,,,thats to help striking but obviously not restrike.....its good policy on critical work to only use full rods, too easy to make restrike defects

Some even use "nobbling" where they strike outside the joint and create a "nobble" of weld

 

[Gingle]

WOW

 

[Tangledfeet]

Have not tried esab ok rods heard good words about them however only i can only compare the BOC to Machine Mart and some old SIP rods.

Have seen they are a bit pricy however

Do you ever visit Dundee? Highland Industrial Supply is the closest ESAB welding supplier to me as I'm at t'other end of Fife. Never tried BOC rods but do have some Nikko 7018's to try.

I've also found that the price on the shelf/label is usually more than you actually pay at the desk...

 

[Lewis_RX8]

Do you ever visit Dundee? Highland Industrial Supply is the closest ESAB welding supplier to me as I'm at t'other end of Fife. Never tried BOC rods but do have some Nikko 7018's to try.

I've also found that the price on the shelf/label is usually more than you actually pay at the desk...

View attachment 249811

I am up that way, some times will have to give that shop a try seem a lot more reasonable on the pricing there and as the BOC dealer, I go to indeed is normally cheaper than shown on the web.

Not sure on 7018's for me as my old welder is at 50v Open circuit which I understand is on the low side for 7018's however I can think of a good solution for this problem

 

[Tangledfeet]

Not sure on 7018's for me as my old welder is at 50v Open circuit which I understand is on the low side for 7018's however I can think of a good solution for this problem

Must crack open the pack and give them a whirl as my inverter shouldn't struggle with 7018's.

Aah, new welding machine time!

 

[Mpm welding]

7018's are low penetration just like 6013's and I do use em post opening, but like i said you may aswell use 6013's at this point as if 70k psi break can't drop to 60k, you shouldn't be using them. Tell you what though, I found 40 loose Esab46.00 at the back of my workshop a few months back, elastic band round them ready for a job, I couldn't believe it when they ran like new. 3 year old! Lol