Anyone know the difference between regulated and reportable? I have read it but it doesn't appear to explain that.
Anyone know the difference between regulated and reportable? I have read it but it doesn't appear to explain that.
These days, anything seems to be reportable. If you shout "bang" loudly enough, chances are there'll be an armed police response, with a bomb disposal unit not far behind!!! ;-))Anyone know the difference between regulated and reportable? I have read it but it doesn't appear to explain that.
I had an open container of brick acid I’d used to clean some horseshoe, the fumes ruined the chrome on my spanners and the rollers on my mitre saw stand.I remember using it to clean rust off steel parts when I lived in the far east. I left an open bucket in my locked up (for the safety nazis) workshop while I went offshore for six weeks. When I got home again everything of bare steel in the workshop was covered in rust.
Be careful with HCL - gives off very nasty fumes - use only in well ventilated areas or with a full face gas mask.
You need to play with it but I’ve a 20l container and tend to 3/4 fill that with water and fire in a decent glug of acid. That tends to take about 24 hours to de scale and de dross a 1/2” plate. If it fizzes when it goes in then that seems to be a good sign.Tell me more how long in the acid and how long and in what to neutarilese it.
This is correct, i was going to use ferric chloride, but then discovered this cupric chloride stuff, that sounded nice because you can easily regenerate it, and just for hobbyist use this sounds good.This cupric chloride Jim's after is used by hobbyists because you can "regenerate" the solution by bubbling air though it and topping it off with a bit more HCL, someone on Instructables boldly claimed it's better than ferric chloride a few years ago and no one seems to have questioned it. Supposedly it's better because you never have to throw away old solution, you just bubble in air or add a splash of acid. Of course eventually you'll end up with a huge amount of etchant because you're never getting rid of the old copper ions, so it only makes sense for hobbyists doing very small quantities, doing it professionally you'll quickly have so much etchant that you'll still have to pay to dispose of it, so you may as well just use ferric chloride and not have to deal with rusty fumes.

Buy copper sulphate and electrolyze it to plate out copper metal and sulphuric acid. 500g makes about 2 litres around 10% and is what I use for anodising.In general, you can’t buy sulfuric acid, in any form, otherwise I could thicken it by increasing the concentration. For small galvanic experiments, you will have to issue a license.
With hydrochloric acid, in theory, you can make sulfuric acid, but this is a long fuss.
You can do it, but you don't want to. A lot of fuss.Buy copper sulphate and electrolyze it to plate out copper metal and sulphuric acid. 500g makes about 2 litres around 10% and is what I use for anodising.

i was going to use ferric chloride, but then discovered this cupric chloride stuff, that sounded nice because you can easily regenerate it,
Nah, with a lead anode, few minutes to set up and let it run until complete. With a graphite anode, yes its a lot of fuss replacing graphite and filtering the carbon.You can do it, but you don't want to. A lot of fuss.![]()

I have a fair few parts I get made up and getting the mill scale off can be a ball ache. Thus sounds like a good idea to me. I may have to try it on the batch I have here to paint.You need to play with it but I’ve a 20l container and tend to 3/4 fill that with water and fire in a decent glug of acid. That tends to take about 24 hours to de scale and de dross a 1/2” plate. If it fizzes when it goes in then that seems to be a good sign.
I then take it out and run it under the tap. I’ve another container I put the metal in and cover it with water. Tip in some bicarbonate (cheap as hell from cash and carry) till litmus strips show ph neutral.
Not very scientific but it works. You could probably get away with just rinsing it.
The acid particularly likes to eat the steel around the HAZ if it’s been flame / plasma cut so keep an eye on that
Does it flash rust after though.I have a fair few parts I get made up and getting the mill scale off can be a ball ache. Thus sounds like a good idea to me. I may have to try it on the batch I have here to paint.
Kind of.Does it flash rust after though.
Have you tried citric? If HCl is taking 24h, its quite dilute and may aswell be citric. It will not cause flash or even slow rust, my welding bench has been outside for nearly 2 years unpainted. Wont harm other items nearby and importantly, is more compatable with most plastic containers - big containers are hard to find in the right shape.I have a fair few parts I get made up and getting the mill scale off can be a ball ache. Thus sounds like a good idea to me. I may have to try it on the batch I have here to paint.

Similar happend when a B&Q orange plastic bucket ignited in my mancupboard almost and hour after I'd stopped welding . I'd checked every thing was safe , went indoors for teatime , came out the bathroom after washing up for the evening meal , looked out the bedroom window and saw it well alight , I hosepipe killed it , but every unpainted surface of metal in my mancupboard save for stainless steel from an old dead dish washer was attacked by the acidic fumes. Happily my antique lathe was sheeted over & well oiled up and not affected. Spent the next fortnight washing everything in hot soapy water with a cloth or green Scotchbrite pan scrubber then having washed things off in clean warm water & dried them off gave most things a spray & wipe over with of WD 40 to protect things .Years ago a customer brought me the extruder from a secondhand plastic injection molding machine he had just bought. Boss was away on holiday, so I was in charge. Asked if I could get it apart as it was seized. Connected up the heaters etc and left it to warm up a couple of hours. Walked back in to find out it had been full of PVC. Acrid smoke everywhere
Came apart easy enough. Next day everything steel in the workshop was rusty. The workbenches looked like shadow boards as what ever had been on them had masked the steel from the rust. Boss wasn’t best impressed on his return![]()
Maybe I'll try citric first as i have some here. It does flash rust after use well the stuff i derusted did. Do I need to.neutraliseit.after of just a rinse with water.Have you tried citric? If HCl is taking 24h, its quite dilute and may aswell be citric. It will not cause flash or even slow rust, my welding bench has been outside for nearly 2 years unpainted. Wont harm other items nearby and importantly, is more compatable with most plastic containers - big containers are hard to find in the right shape.



