Seadog
Save the planet. It's the only one with rum!
- Messages
- 11,457
- Location
- NE London - UK
I thought that I had a lot of holders, but you've beaten me by 7On my lathe, if I used 16 mm tools (or 5/8") exclusively then the Dixon toolpost would be fine (although I prefer the big clamping lever on the Aloris style as I don't have to reach for a separate tool to clamp).
However, I don't exclusively use 16 mm tools. I often use 12 mm and 10 mm tools and occasionally smaller ones than that. If I've got to grind a custom shape into a bit of HSS, it's a lot quicker to do it on a bit of 8 mm HSS than it is to do it on a bit of 16 mm HSS. For the really small HSS pieces, I can use tool holders like these ones, but for something like a 10 mm tool, it's simpler just to put the tool in a tool holder directly. On the Dixon toolpost, I'd have to put some packing material underneath the 10 mm tool to get the tip up to centre height. With the Aloris one, I don't have to.
Another benefit of the Aloris style tool post is it's a heck of a lot easier to make your own tool holders as the shape is quite simple: just a dovetail. I've made quite a few: all the non-blackened ones in this photo:
View attachment 424447